English or Italian Cloth?
How the two traditions differ in the hand, who really weaves the cloth, and which to choose in Singapore.
English suiting is traditionally heavier, firmer and drier in the hand, made to hold a shape and a crease. Italian suiting is traditionally lighter, softer and smoother, made to drape. Neither is better. The name on the cloth may belong to a mill, which weaves it, or to a merchant, which commissions it and sells it to tailors by the length.
English vs Italian cloth is a real difference, but it describes a tradition more than a place. Italian mills weave for English merchants, and one English cloth was first made for Hong Kong and Singapore. Before you choose, it helps to know who makes the cloth, who sells it, and what the label can tell you.
Mill or merchant: what is the difference?
A mill weaves cloth. A merchant designs or selects cloth, has mills weave it, holds it in stock and sells it to tailors a suit-length at a time. The swatches bound into books on a tailor’s table are called bunches, and many of them come from merchants.
The two hold different things. As Simon Crompton of Permanent Style describes the trade, a mill holds yarn and weaves to order, and does not usually sell short lengths. A merchant holds finished cloth, so a tailor can buy the few metres that one suit needs.
For a tailor, both matter. Mills give depth in the cloths they are known for. Merchants give range, and many of their cloths stay in stock from year to year, so a second pair of trousers can still be cut later.
The line between them is not clean. Some merchants own mills, and some mills sell under their own name. The two countries also work differently. Italian mills more often spin, weave and finish under one roof. English mills usually weave only, and a separate finisher completes the cloth.
These are some of the houses in our cloth library, by country and in the order they were founded. Each has its own page, from Fox Brothers and Dugdale Bros & Co to Scabal, Dormeuil and Ermenegildo Zegna.
English and British houses
| House | What it is | Since |
|---|---|---|
| Fox Brothers | Mill in Somerset, best known for flannel | 1772 |
| Thomas Mason | Shirting name, owned by Italy’s Albini since 1992 | 1796 |
| Holland & Sherry | Merchant, London | 1836 |
| Dormeuil | French merchant, now also making cloth in Yorkshire | 1842 |
| Brisbane Moss | Cotton mill, known for corduroy and moleskin | 1858 |
| Standeven | Mill and merchant, Yorkshire | 1885 |
| Dugdale Bros & Co | Merchant, Huddersfield | 1896 |
| Scabal | Belgian merchant with its own mill near Huddersfield | 1938 |
Italian houses
| House | What it is | Since |
|---|---|---|
| Vitale Barberis Canonico | Wool mill, Biella | 1663 |
| Reda | Wool mill, Biella | 1865 |
| Solbiati | Linen mill, owned by Loro Piana since 2010 | 1874 |
| Albini | Shirting mill, near Bergamo | 1876 |
| Tallia di Delfino | Wool mill, Biella | 1903 |
| Ermenegildo Zegna | Wool mill, Trivero | 1910 |
| Loro Piana | Began as a merchant, now also a maker | 1924 |
| Drapers | Merchant, Bologna, owned by Vitale Barberis Canonico since 2018 | 1956 |
| Lanificio Colombo | Cashmere mill, Valsesia | 1967 |
| Drago | Wool mill, Biella | 1973 |
What is English cloth like?
Dry, firm and matte. English suitings were made for a cool, damp country and for structured tailoring, and between the wars they started at about 13 ounces. A cloth like that holds a trouser crease and hangs straight from the shoulder.
The classic English cloths are worsteds from Yorkshire, flannel from the West of England, and tweed. Fox Brothers has made cloth in Wellington, Somerset since 1772 and is best known for flannel. Holland & Sherry began as merchants at 10 Old Bond Street in London in 1836.
Much of the finest English worsted still comes from in and around Huddersfield, in West Yorkshire. Dugdale Bros & Co, merchants there since 1896, have their collections made within ten miles of the office.
What is Italian cloth like?
Soft, light and smooth, often with a slight sheen. Italian mills are known for fine yarns and light weights, which suit lightly built jackets and warm weather.
Many of Italy’s best-known wool mills sit in one corner of Piedmont, around Biella. Vitale Barberis Canonico, established in 1663, weaves there and by 2016 was producing about nine million metres a year. Reda has been at Valle Mosso since 1865. Loro Piana, founded in Quarona in 1924, started as a merchant of cashmere, vicuña, linen and merino.
English and Italian cloth, side by side
| Quality | English | Italian |
|---|---|---|
| Hand | Dry and firm | Soft and smooth |
| Surface | Usually matte | Often a slight sheen |
| Weight | Traditionally heavier | Traditionally lighter |
| Drape | Hangs straight, holds a crease | Flows, follows the body |
| Suits | Structured tailoring, trousers, hard wear | Soft tailoring, jackets, warm weather |
These are habits, not rules. Flannel shows both sides. Permanent Style’s guide to flannel notes that English flannels are usually set more closely and woven from thicker yarn, so they weigh more, while Italian flannels tend the other way, with exceptions in both countries. Judge the cloth in your hand, not the flag on the label.
Is the cloth woven where the name says?
Not always. A merchant’s name tells you who chose the cloth, not where the loom stands. Crompton notes that many Italian mills weave ranges for merchants outside Italy. Vitale Barberis Canonico sells about half of what it weaves under its own name and the rest under other names, English and Italian merchants among them.
Ownership crosses borders too. Scabal is a Belgian house with a mill in Huddersfield. Dormeuil is French and makes cloth in Yorkshire. Thomas Mason, a British shirting name founded in 1796, has belonged to Italy’s Albini Group since 1992.
So read English and Italian as a description of the cloth first. If the origin matters to you, look at the selvedge or the bunch label, which often says where the cloth was made, or ask us at the consultation.
How to read a cloth label
The selvedge is the woven edge of the cloth, and makers often weave their name into it. A bunch label usually adds four things: the composition, the weight, a Super number if the wool is fine, and the name of the collection.
Read the weight first. It is given in grams per metre or in ounces per yard, and for everyday suits in Singapore we look for about 240 to 280 grams. Then the weave, since an open weave lets more air through than a close one. Then the composition. The Super number tells you how fine the wool fibre is, which is not the same as how good the cloth is: our guide to Super numbers explains why.
Which works in Singapore?
Either, if the weight and the weave are right. It is tempting to rule out English cloth as too warm, yet some of the best-known warm-weather cloths are English. Fresco was registered in 1907 by Martin Sons & Co, now part of Huddersfield Fine Worsteds. It is a high-twist worsted in a porous plain weave, and so well known that other high-twist cloths are often called fresco.
Dugdale’s Tropicalair has a closer tie to this part of the world. It was first made in the 1960s for the Hong Kong and Singapore market, for customers who wanted wool with something of the feel of linen.
Neither is especially light: both sit at around 280 to 310 grams. They wear cooler than their weight suggests because the weave is open. Italian mills answer the heat another way, with light worsteds and with blends of wool, silk and linen. The best suit fabrics for Singapore’s heat compares them all.
Which should you choose?
For a suit you will wear hard
A firmer cloth, English in character, keeps its shape and its crease.
For a jacket to wear on its own
A softer Italian cloth, perhaps a wool, silk and linen blend, drapes more easily.
For Singapore’s heat
Weave and weight matter more than country. Ask for an open, high-twist weave, from either side.
For a wedding
Choose for the venue and the hour before the country. Our wedding suit guide matches cloth to venue.
If you can’t decide
Handle both. How to choose a suit fabric is a good place to begin.
What clients ask us
Is English or Italian cloth better?
Neither. English cloth is traditionally firmer and holds its shape, and Italian cloth is traditionally lighter and softer. The right one depends on the garment and how you will wear it.
What is the difference between a mill and a cloth merchant?
A mill weaves cloth. A merchant designs or selects cloth, has mills weave it, keeps it in stock and sells it to tailors by the length. Some merchants also own mills.
Is cloth from an English merchant always woven in England?
No. A merchant’s name shows who selected the cloth, and some Italian mills weave for merchants outside Italy. The selvedge or the bunch label often says where a cloth was made.
Is English cloth too warm for Singapore?
Not if the weave is open. High-twist English cloths such as Fresco let air through, and Dugdale’s Tropicalair was first made for Hong Kong and Singapore. Weight and weave matter more than the country.
Is Scabal a mill or a merchant?
Both. Scabal was founded as a cloth merchant in Brussels in 1938 and acquired a mill in Huddersfield, England, in 1973.
Cloth is chosen by hand. Book a consultation and we will put English and Italian bunches side by side on the table.
Written by the ŠAKAL atelier, bespoke tailors in Singapore since 2019.
Sources
- Simon Crompton, “Huddersfield’s mills and merchants explained”, Permanent Style (2013)
- Simon Crompton, “Italy’s mills and merchants explained”, Permanent Style (2013)
- Permanent Style, “The guide to flannel” (2017)
- Permanent Style, “A guide to high-twist bunches” (2019)
- Christopher Lee, “British vs. Italian vs. American – Suit Fashions & Silhouettes”, Gentleman’s Gazette (30 August 2019)
- Wikipedia, “Vitale Barberis Canonico”
- Wikipedia, “Fox Brothers”
- Wikipedia, “Holland & Sherry”
- Wikipedia, “Loro Piana”
- Wikipedia, “Dormeuil”
- Wikipedia, “Thomas Mason (apparel)”
- Scabal, “Heritage”
- Dugdale Bros & Co, “About”
- Huddersfield Fine Worsteds, “Heritage”
- ŠAKAL, “Reda”